The Grey Stuff Cookies

The Grey Stuff Cookies

Who doesn’t love a cookies ‘n’ cream Disney treat?! Years ago I came up with my own version of The Grey Stuff for Disney Dinners: Beauty and the Beast. Since it was a dinner party, I piped delicious cookies ‘n’ cream whipped cream on top of super rich fudge brownies for a decadent dessert. For my Beauty and the Beast Tea, I decided to do a slightly different version and serve The Grey Stuff on cute little sugar cookie rounds for the perfect tea time dessert.

The Grey Stuff Cookies

The Grey Stuff Recipe Beauty and the Beast Food | The Rose Table
The Rose Table’s original version of The Grey Stuff


The Grey Stuff Cookies

When I baked my Teapot Sugar Cookies, I used the dough to bake one sheet of small rounds that I cut out with a biscuit cutter. The day before my party, I made The Grey Stuff and piped it on top of the sugar cookies. I carefully set the delightful mounds in a deep tupperware and popped it in the fridge overnight. Proof that The Grey Stuff will hold its shape! I still have some leftover days later and it still looks perfect so don’t be afraid to make this the day before your party.

The Grey Stuff CookiesThe Grey Stuff Cookies

The Grey Stuff Cookies
Ready for the fridge!

I hope you love this magical Disney treat as much as I do! I’ve lost track of how many times I’ve made The Grey Stuff.

The Grey Stuff Cookies

The Grey Stuff Cookies
Sugar cookie rounds
1 cup heavy whipping cream
1 tsp vanilla extract
1/4 cup powdered sugar
7 Oreos (regular, not double stuffed)

  1. Bake sugar cookies. (See my teacup sugar cookie recipe.)
  2. Finely crush oreos in a food processor.
  3. Beat whipping cream with a metal whisk in a metal bowl until it thickens. Add vanilla, and powdered sugar. Beat until soft peaks form.
  4. Stir in crushed oreos. Your mixture should be grey.
  5. Spoon into piping bag fitted with a large metal tip. (I used a Wilton No. 2D Large Drop Flower Piping Tip.) Pipe onto sugar cookie rounds.
Beauty and the Beast Tea Party
Photo credit: @shefliesfromdallas

Read more about my Beauty and the Beast Tea here. Watch the episode:

Make your own magic,

Don’t forget to follow/like The Rose Table on FacebookTwitter, and Instagram! Sign up for The Rose Table’s emails here. Get The Rose Table Cookbook here. Shop my merch here.

Leave a Reply